Retail Sales, Discount Stores, and Why the U.S. Market Can’t Collapse (Yet)
Retail Sales: What the Data Is Really Telling Us
Recent Retail Sales data in the United States must be read with care. On the surface, the numbers can look softer than expected, leading to headlines about a “slowing consumer” or “fragile demand.” However, the underlying structure of American consumption tells a different story.
Today, U.S. consumer demand is supported by two key elements:
- Stable employment levels
- Positive real wage growth, with average earnings and wages rising around 0.90%–1.50% year-on-year
High interest rates on loans, credit cards, and mortgages have certainly changed behavior, but not in the way many commentators suggest. Consumers have not dramatically reduced their purchases. Instead, they have reallocated their spending toward medium- and medium-low-priced goods and services.
From Premium to Price-Conscious: The Shift in U.S. Consumption
The key change in U.S. consumption is less about volume and more about price:
- Households are still buying.
- They are simply buying cheaper alternatives.
This shift from higher-priced to mid- and low-priced products means that the average price per item declines, even if the number of items purchased remains stable or slightly higher. As a result, headline Retail Sales—especially in categories excluding auto parts and gas stations—can appear weaker than the underlying demand really is.
In other words, the Retail Sales value may grow more slowly not because the consumer is disappearing, but because the consumer is optimizing.
Proof in the Market: NVDA vs. the Discount Retailers
To test this thesis, we can look away from economic theory and focus on market evidence. Consider the performance of:
- NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA) – a high-profile tech and AI market star
- Dollar General Corporation (DG) – Discount Stores, Market Cap ≈ 27.35B
- Dollar Tree, Inc. (DLTR) – Discount Stores, Market Cap ≈ 24.54B
Recent performance:
- NVDA – YTD: +38.21%, 1Y: +33.71%
- DG – YTD: +68.11%, 1Y: +56.22%
- DLTR – YTD: +60.57%, 1Y: +68.06%
While NVDA represents the speculative and technological heart of the market, DG and DLTR reflect what is happening in the shopping carts of everyday Americans. Their strong performance is consistent with a shift toward discount and value-focused consumption.
The Walmart Signal: Three Years of Structural Change
The story becomes even clearer when we look at Walmart Inc. (WMT), a dominant player in everyday retail:
- WMT YTD: +26.63%
- WMT 1Y: +22.21%
- WMT 3Y: +142.69%
These numbers are not a short-term anomaly. They show that the trend towards discount and value-oriented purchasing started around three years ago. The current environment of higher interest rates has amplified this ongoing rotation, and in 2025 the market has broadened its recognition, rewarding several names in the discount retail space.
Put simply: the Walmart data confirms that this is a structural shift in consumer behavior, not a temporary reaction.
How This Affects Retail Sales Interpretation
When analyzing Retail Sales—especially Retail Sales excluding auto and gas—it is crucial to keep this reality in mind:
- It is not primarily a story of reduced quantity.
- It is a story of a lower average ticket price.
Because more spending is migrating into discount channels and lower price points, the nominal value of Retail Sales can understate the resilience of the U.S. consumer. Without this context, analysts risk confusing a shift in price mix with a collapse in demand.
Why the Market Is Still Supported
From a market perspective, this combination is powerful:
- Employment remains stable.
- Real wages are growing modestly but positively.
- Consumers are adapting intelligently by trading down, not dropping out.
- Discount retailers and value-focused businesses are reporting strong performance.
The equity market is ultimately a reflection of discounted future cash flows. As long as the U.S. consumption engine continues to run—even with a different mix—the system retains its lifeline. In this environment, the market:
- Must not fall, because the core demand engine is intact.
- Will not fall easily, because earnings are being supported in key sectors.
- Cannot fall deeply, as long as employment and real wages remain stable and discount channels absorb the pressure of higher rates.
Conclusion: “Hic manebimus optime”
The Latin phrase “Hic manebimus optime” means: “Here we shall remain, and here we remain very well.”
Applied to today’s U.S. market, it captures the reality that:
- The consumer has not disappeared.
- The consumer has changed strategy.
- The market is adjusting to this new pattern of demand, not collapsing under it.
When reading Retail Sales data, it is therefore essential to look beyond the headline number and understand where the dollars are flowing. For now, the message is clear: the U.S. consumer is still here, spending differently— and that is enough to keep the system, and the market, alive and well.